Current:Home > MarketsKentucky Supreme Court strikes down new law giving participants right to change venue-InfoLens
Kentucky Supreme Court strikes down new law giving participants right to change venue
View Date:2024-12-23 15:14:40
FRANKFORT, Ky. (AP) — Kentucky’s Supreme Court on Thursday struck down a new state law that allowed participants in constitutional challenges to get the cases switched to randomly selected counties. The court said the legislature’s action on the assignment of court cases encroached on judicial authority.
The law, enacted this year over the governor’s veto, allowed any participants to request changes of venue for civil cases challenging the constitutionality of laws, orders or regulations. It required the clerk of the state Supreme Court to choose another court through a random selection.
Such constitutional cases typically are heard in Franklin County Circuit Court in the capital city of Frankfort. For years, Republican officials have complained about a number of rulings from Franklin circuit judges in high-stakes cases dealing with constitutional issues.
The high court’s ruling was a victory for Democratic Gov. Andy Beshear, who in his veto message denounced the measure as an “unconstitutional power grab” by the state’s GOP-dominated legislature. Lawmakers overrode the governor’s veto, sparking the legal fight that reached the state’s highest court.
Republican Attorney General Daniel Cameron’s office defended the venue law, which passed as Senate Bill 126. Cameron is challenging Beshear in the Nov. 7 gubernatorial election — one of the nation’s highest-profile campaigns this year.
Writing for the court’s majority, Chief Justice Laurance B. VanMeter said the new law amounted to a violation of constitutional separation of powers.
The measure granted “unchecked power to a litigant to remove a judge from a case under the guise of a “transfer,” circumventing the established recusal process, the chief justice wrote.
“It operates to vest a certain class of litigants with the unfettered right to forum shop, without having to show any bias on the part of the presiding judge, or just cause for removal,” VanMeter said.
The measure also resulted in “divesting the circuit court of its inherent jurisdiction and authority to decide when and if a case should be transferred to another venue,” he said.
Responding to the ruling, Cameron’s office insisted the legislature had acted within its authority.
“The legislature has always had broad authority to decide where lawsuits should be heard,” the attorney general’s office said in a statement. “Today’s opinion backtracks on that established principle and diminishes the power of the people’s branch of government.”
In a dissenting opinion, Justice Robert Conley said the legislature has the constitutional authority to pass legislation “fixing venue and providing for changes of venue.”
“SB126 is new and it is different from what the judiciary is used to,” he wrote. “I deem it unwise, imprudent, inefficient and inexpedient. But I cannot say it is unconstitutional.”
In his March veto message, Beshear said the measure was aimed at one court. The intent, he said, was to “control Kentucky courts and block any civil action alleging a law is unconstitutional from being heard in one circuit court: the Franklin Circuit Court.”
veryGood! (165)
Related
- Gun groups sue to overturn Maine’s new three-day waiting period to buy firearms
- Skier dies, 2 others injured after falling about 1,000 feet in Alaska avalanche: They had all the right gear
- There are more than 300 headache causes. These are the most common ones.
- Outer Banks Star Austin North Speaks Out After Arrest Over Alleged Hospital Attack
- Lee Zeldin, Trump’s EPA Pick, Brings a Moderate Face to a Radical Game Plan
- Inter Miami preseason match Thursday: Will Lionel Messi play against hometown club?
- GMA3's T.J. Holmes Reveals When He First Knew He Loved Amy Robach
- Mississippi seeing more teacher vacancies
- Alexandra Daddario Shares Candid Photo of Her Postpartum Body 6 Days After Giving Birth
- Does 'Feud: Capote Vs. The Swans' ruffle enough feathers
Ranking
- Spurs coach Gregg Popovich had a stroke earlier this month, is expected to make full recovery
- Special counsel urges Supreme Court to deny Trump's bid to halt decision rejecting immunity claim in 2020 election case
- Lake Mead's water levels measure highest since 2021 after 'Pineapple Express' slams California
- Kentucky House passes bills allowing new academic roles for Murray State and Eastern Kentucky
- Democratic state leaders prepare for a tougher time countering Trump in his second term
- What to know about Thursday's Daytona Duels, the qualifying races for the 2024 Daytona 500
- Ford CEO says company will rethink where it builds vehicles after last year’s autoworkers strike
- In a first, Oscar-nominated short ‘The Last Repair Shop’ to air on broadcast television
Recommendation
-
Whoopi Goldberg Shares Very Relatable Reason She's Remained on The View
-
Michigan school shooter’s father wants a jury from outside the community
-
Pennsylvania mom convicted of strangling 11-year-old son, now faces life sentence
-
You'll Swoon Over Millie Bobby Brown and Jake Bongiovi's Valentine's Day Date
-
Bull doge! Dogecoin soars as Trump announces a government efficiency group nicknamed DOGE
-
Skier dies, 2 others injured after falling about 1,000 feet in Alaska avalanche: They had all the right gear
-
LSU RB Trey Holly arrested in connection with shooting that left two people injured
-
16-year-old boy arrested in NYC subway shooting that killed 1 and wounded 5